undefined | Better HN

story

0 pointspassivate4y ago0 comments

IMO, That is a bit of an odd position to take. The terms of the deal were very clear going in.

I don't owe Donald Knuth anything more than the $100 (placeholder) for his books, even if they helped me get a 6 figure job right out of college.

Yes, his books had a lot more "value" than $100, but those were the terms of the deal.

0 comments

ehnto4y ago

I don't expect any monetary recuperation, you're right in that the deal was clear to begin with. Just like I don't expect a cut of ad-revenue from a forum or what-have-you.

I just don't feel it's correct to say that the contributions actually had no monetary value, they definitely did, it's just that we handed it to Stack Overflow for free in exchange for participating in the platform.

I don't think it's unreasonable to feel a little bit jaded about it either. I'm not, I didn't contribute nearly enough to feel entitled to squat. But I get it.

passivateOP4y ago

I think we would largely agree on the meat and potatoes - we just have a small disagreement of opinion, no biggie :)

>I just don't feel it's correct to say that the contributions actually had no monetary value, they definitely did, it's just that we handed it to Stack Overflow for free in exchange for participating in the platform.

How did you know the answer had value when you typed it up? The value is not solely determined by you or me - It's by the large number of visitors/viewers actually benefiting from the answer. And you need both, the platform attracting tons of readers, and the high-quality answer.

Certainly, there is lots that can be said here to expand on that and add more nuance, but not in a comment box.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse