People are free to gamble, but could they please not turn the surface of the Earth into a black body radiator while they're at it?
The creator of the Keurig, a device which produces amazing amounts of waste, talked about the unintended consequences of his invention and how ashamed he is for the damage his invention has done.
I'm not sure if we can that easily pin the responsibility on a single person and not on every single one who still continue to go for PoW while knowing how destructive it is.
You can see the carbon footprint from different blockchains on https://coincarboncap.com
A transaction meaning transferring money from one wallet to another?
There's a lot of energy to secure the network, but the actual energy usage per transaction itself is a small fraction of that misquoted number.
Generally speaking, every 10 minutes! one block is mined which is incentivived with 6 btc or roughlyl the equivilent of over 150.000$.
In avg there are 1000-2000 transactions per block.
I was with you up until this part...this kind of over-dramatization might turn others away. I can think of several genocidal dictators worse than Satoshi Nakamoto. If anything Satoshi is an Alfred Nobel type figure, who invented dynamite. We don't attribute all deaths from explosions to Alfred Nobel, and Satoshi is not guilty of what miners and speculators do.
Satoshi actually made the most efficient decentralized money that can ever exist and prevented more externalities in the world than potentially any human ever will.
Cars monitor energy use through MPG. Datacenters monitor it as well. Why should crypto currencies get a pass?
> Satoshi actually made the most efficient decentralized money that can ever exist and prevented more externalities in the world than potentially any human ever will.
[CITATION NEEDED]
Bitcoin and the Nakamoto Consensus is a breakthrough that provides a secure, global, uncensorable, decentralized store of value. With defined rules that can't be changed on the whims of a central actor. The energy is used to prevent bad actors from being able to rewrite the blockchain. Per transaction is a misleading metric (plus there are layer 2 solutions). You have to consider the energy used by militaries and banks to secure fiat.
When your government fails, as they have in many countries and eventually do in the long span of history, having such a store of value will be, well... invaluable.
If, ever, it so happens that cryptocurrencies become anything more than a joke from the point of view of the global economy, militaries and banks will be required to secure their operations too.
Most people don't seem to realize that a store of value is stable.
Today ( just as in 2017 till the pandemic) has proven that BTC/crypto is not stable.
It has more similarities with a MLM scheme ( not really backed by anything ( eg. Stable coins - tether), unregulated, limited withdrawals of your money on the exchange).
I don't believe anyone actually thinks BTC is safer while it's influenced by memes instead of actual market conditions. Well, except if the reason is greed and personal liability ofc.
Ps. The only reason to have some crypto coins is for diversifying your portfolio. If you consider the risks carefully, as with everything else.
I don't buy in the energy argument myself, but trying to justify the way you do sounds a little too kool-aid-y.
The NYGA report on Tether is due today. Tether is completely insolvent, and once the rug is pulled, all of the exchanges are going to realize that all of their "stable" reserves are worthless and they can't pay out what they're storing for customers, and the price will tumble all the way down as there's a run on the pseudo-banks that can't payout.
Or not, what do I know.
We all know it's insolvent. Apparently it doesn't matter.
The same is true for other types of money - a bank does not hold reserves (assets) against all of its deposits (liabilities), but that does not prevent it from operating, or from bank customers understanding bank deposits as “real money”.
To be clear, I’m not very informed about tether, and as a lay person I do find it to be a shocking situation that probably makes sense to label as fraud. I’m just trying to offer some explanation.
You know, the whole benefit of being in the USD. The made up rules of society that provide stability in times of crisis.
Given the price volatility of crypto, that sounds absolutely insane to me. Also, I don't think this prevents a run, on the contrary, when everyone hits the sell button and cannot actually exit then panic will ensue.
On the day you might think that limit matters, it's not really gonna matter.
Presumably, people can sell all their holdings and withdraw over time.
Personally I don’t care - let it collapse if they did anything shady, but this zerohedge-esque “broken clock” strategy is extremely amusing.
If you are confident about the long term prospects of an investment, then holding on for longer might just work. I won't be selling any of my Eth or PoS crypto currencies any time soon. It helps that crypto makes up less than 15% of my portfolio.
Also, people in China would call it "unplug" when exchanges going down. It's a popular meme because people find every time the market crashes those Chinese exchanges would go down as well, thus many people believe they intentionally did that to let oligarchs sell their crypto in back channels first.
(hard to get a site that is up and has a good chart for that rn..)
Posted on HN a while back.
"To be crystal clear: every time you sell Tethers on Kraken, you are forcing Tether Ltd. to pay you in US dollars. If you can manage to sell enough Tethers for USD on Kraken, then Tether Ltd. will run out of dollars and this whole machine — which currently undergirds 70% of all crypto trading flows — will fall apart.
Well-capitalized hedge fund managers may wish to re-read the above paragraph, and ponder its implications."
Sounds like it could be three things:
1) Their USD standard is bunk. If you're on a commodity money - or secondary exchange money - standard then you can only issue as many certs as there are units of that money in your reserves. With the XAU standard, you can't just mint gold certs without gold underlying it. That's not how any of this works!
2) They just FDR'ed their users, and took them off the USD standard but didn't tell them.
3) Less technically: sounds like they're skimming off the USD for themselves and hoping everyone doesn't divest at the same time. This could be either fraud, or it could just be incomitance, ignorance or any other *ance really.
Please link to the HN article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25788409
Jump to the 7d view
But otherwise: smart move. :D
Was just going to ask what you would recommend to monitor that. In better times, what would be the best resources?
https://www.cnn.com/2021/05/19/investing/bitcoin-price-drop-...
It’s fascinating stuff to follow — watch the VIX today, a measure of stock market volatility. It’s absolutely soaring already.
There are several days in the last month, according to Tether, with AT LEAST $500M of inflows.
A single $1B of outflows shouldn't tank a market like this by 40%...
It depends what kind of market you think it is. The fact is there's no economic fundamental supporting the value of Bitcoin, so it's value is just whatever speculators are willing to pay at any given time.
[0] https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1394170030741413888
[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2021/05/16/elon-musk-suggests-tesla-is-...
Introducing: Server Trouble As A Service. The most efficient way to stop a run on your bank.
Edit: Also: Since most people need USD to get Bitcoin (or other coins), doesn't that mean all cryptocurrencies are inherently gold-backed and rely on the value-store of gold? (Excuse my naive question. Again; I'm a newbie).
That was the original intent, but it's been known for years now that cryptocurrencies just don't work for that scenario. As soon as volume grows, transaction times and costs soar to levels that are unsustainable for actual payments. So most cryptocurrencies have since turned into speculative digital commodities, arbitrary items that get value out of being unregulated, transnational, and anonymous or pseudonymous. They allow money to flow internationally outside of the official banking system, untroubled by pesky anti-money-laundering laws or anything protecting investors. Exchanges on the fringes deal with the trouble of converting them back into money and goods... at least as long as governments allow them to do it.
It hasn't been about actually using it for years now.
Kinda weird you left that out but mentioned stealing, although I suppose ransomware is top of mind these days.
Are you saying Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are inherently gold-backed like the USD?
https://www.reddit.com/r/binance/comments/nea291/weekly_bina...
https://www.cnn.com/2021/05/19/investing/bitcoin-price-drop-...
"Investigating - We are currently investigating this issue. May 19, 06:12 PDT"
Which also asks the next question, how much of the price action and volume is automated trading in these platforms?
Not that automated is necessarily good or bad - but how much is a retail interest
In fact I think you could turn that into a partial numerical measure of the crypto market. In a mature market where "cryptocurrenciness" is mostly just a fact of life, they ought to be less correlated as they have independent lives of some sort. (They'll never be completely uncorrelated, of course, since the whole market is correlated to some degree.) Right now it's still enough of a novelty that the mere fact of cryptocurrenciness is a big percentage of the appeal of a given cryptocurrency.
Estimates put 65-75% of BTC mining in China. That just became a pretty shaky foundation.
It's not unexpected that they are correlated.
All cryptocurrencies are basically the same and indistinguishable and fulfill the same needs.
I bought a bunch of BTC back in 2018 on Coinbase and just left it there, I rarely checked it. Fast forward to 2021 and I want to see how my portfolio has grown, only to be told my account was disabled. This was back at the beginning of March. So I contacted them and told them my issue. They sent me instructions on changing passwords, calling my mobile service provider etc. Some ridiculous stuff. I did it all. Only for them to tell me that they have to forward my case to a specialist. 3 weeks later, they come back to me telling me to repeat the same steps as I did before, and I complied, only for them to tell me they are again forwarding it to a specialist. Another 3 weeks later, they tell me to repeat the same steps in addition to taking a photo of myself holding my ID with a sign that says 'For Coinbase verification'. Did that degrading stuff too. Guess what they told me again, oops we are forwarding it to a specialist.
I don't know whether it is automated supported or what but this is absolutely disgusting and there is no name to the emails, just 'Coinbase Support'.
As soon as I regained access all took all my shitcoins and moved them to a wallet for which I have the key.
Centralized exchanges suck, they are completely against the principles of Cryptocurrencies.
I can load the rest of Reddit fine - but that page just loads as a blank white page. I'm guessing its lots of people going there for the discussions...
