undefined | Better HN

0 pointsenriquto4y ago0 comments

> you can look at the code, but can't use it in your own projects unless they are open source too or pay for the commercial license.

Please, stop spreading ridiculous FUD.

You can use copylefted code in your own projects without any restriction. It is only when you distribute this copylefted code (e.g., by letting users run it in your computer) that you need to publish your modifications to it. And then, this is only relevant when you have modified the copylefted code; otherwise you just need to distribute code that is public elsewhere, which is a non-issue.

0 comments

MaxBarraclough4y ago

> It is only when you distribute this copylefted code (e.g., by letting users run it in your computer) that you need to publish your modifications to it.

I don't know if that was a typo, but letting users run the software on your computer, isn't 'distribution' in the usual sense. What you said sounds true of the GPL, but doesn't give a complete account of the AGPL.

From the FSF: [0]

> The GNU Affero General Public License is a modified version of the ordinary GNU GPL version 3. It has one added requirement: if you run a modified program on a server and let other users communicate with it there, your server must also allow them to download the source code corresponding to the modified version running there.

[0] https://www.gnu.org/licenses/why-affero-gpl.html

enriqutoOP4y ago

by "your computer" i meant your server. It's the same thing, isn't it?

MaxBarraclough4y ago

Yes, but that isn't distributing copylefted code. If it were, the GPL and the AGPL would be the same licence.

d110af5ccf4y ago

> this is only relevant when you have modified the copylefted code

If I write a program that uses a GPL licensed library but never modify that library, it still infects my entire program. I have created a derivative work under copyright law. It doesn't matter that I never modified the original code that I received.

So if my proprietary SaaS web app makes use of an unmodified AGPL licensed library in order to perform a single computation ...

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsenriquto4y ago0 comments

> you can look at the code, but can't use it in your own projects unless they are open source too or pay for the commercial license.

Please, stop spreading ridiculous FUD.

0 comments

MaxBarraclough4y ago

> It is only when you distribute this copylefted code (e.g., by letting users run it in your computer) that you need to publish your modifications to it.

From the FSF: [0]

[0] https://www.gnu.org/licenses/why-affero-gpl.html

enriqutoOP4y ago

by "your computer" i meant your server. It's the same thing, isn't it?

MaxBarraclough4y ago

Yes, but that isn't distributing copylefted code. If it were, the GPL and the AGPL would be the same licence.

d110af5ccf4y ago

> this is only relevant when you have modified the copylefted code

So if my proprietary SaaS web app makes use of an unmodified AGPL licensed library in order to perform a single computation ...

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse