undefined | Better HN

0 pointsmoolcool4y ago0 comments

The last time the US went into a war because there were malevolent people in the world who posed a direct threat to the nation was in the 1940s

0 comments

exclusiv4y ago

Depends how you define direct threat. The threats changed after WW2 for technological, industrial and economic reasons.

Also, I don't follow the spirit of your comment. The United Nations came out of WW2. And the US is a key member of those coalitions against any malevolent regimes.

Just how it works. A direct threat isn't a thing anymore of relevance when you're a member of a coalition.

ativzzz4y ago

How about the Korean and Vietnam wars? Iraq? Afghanistan? Maybe they weren't officially declared wars like WW1/2 but if sending troops to a country to fight doesn't constitute wars I don't know what does.

moolcoolOP4y ago

The implication of my post is that those wars were not "because there were malevolent people in the world who posed a direct threat to the nation". The US could just as well not have not gone to war in Korea, Vietnam, Iraq, or Afghanistan.

ativzzz4y ago

Pretty sure the rationale for Korea/Vietnam was exactly "because there were malevolent people in the world who posed a direct threat to the nation", just targeted towards the USSR/communism

bromuro4y ago

and what about latin america.

there’s no end to the abuses of the US military around the world, and MS is helping these killers in exchange of money.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

exclusiv4y ago

Depends how you define direct threat. The threats changed after WW2 for technological, industrial and economic reasons.

Also, I don't follow the spirit of your comment. The United Nations came out of WW2. And the US is a key member of those coalitions against any malevolent regimes.

Just how it works. A direct threat isn't a thing anymore of relevance when you're a member of a coalition.

ativzzz4y ago

moolcoolOP4y ago

ativzzz4y ago

Pretty sure the rationale for Korea/Vietnam was exactly "because there were malevolent people in the world who posed a direct threat to the nation", just targeted towards the USSR/communism

bromuro4y ago

and what about latin america.

there’s no end to the abuses of the US military around the world, and MS is helping these killers in exchange of money.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse