You can't change how they operate. But you can change how you operate.
So I should probably lower the quality of my life to make a statement that will have no impact on them at all?
>You can't change how they operate.
Sure you can, by petitioning your government to draft laws and so on.
God forbid we "lower the quality of our lives" for such lowly things as principles!
>Sure you can, by petitioning your government to draft laws and so on.
Else what, you'll vote for another party? Both parties (in the US) take money from Big Tech, and they vote the same shit anyway. That will "show them" nothing. Especially since their stance on such laws is 1/100 of the things you vote a party/candidate about (so you will still vote for them if you agree on other matters).
(Edit: I mention mental wellness because those products, and the ads they carry, are designed to be addictive.)
I use GMail, Google Search, Youtube Twitter, Amazon, and Facebook.
I'm not thrilled about FB but it lets me keep tabs on friends. Sometiems I interact with a few people who are friends but sucked in by a lot of the disinformation around, so I try to engage with them sometimes but not often. I also spend maybe 15 minutes a day on it, tops.
Twitter never stresses me, I don't follow toxic people, just friends, entertainers, tech people and such. Again, maybe 15-30 minutes a day, tops.
I get a lot of satisfaction from Youtube, I even pay for premium so I don't get ads, and follow a bunch of great creators.
Amazon's pricing and delivery are great. that makes me happy. I just make sure not to by crap/scam products and I'm good. I use Amazon Music every day, and their video streaming is great too (although they need to stop changing the name).
Google Search is by far the best, IMO, and saves me hours every day.
I have my personal domain go to gmail, and it makes managing ages of email a breeze.
So I can't see a way in which ditching any of those would benefit me, and aside from Facebook, I feel NOT using them would cause me more stress, or less enjoyment.
I'd love to know how you find leaving them has benefitted you.
Instagram is a great tools for business, and now it's practically impossible to run one without using it. Twitter and reddit can provide you a ton of useful info that you will have a hard time finding anywhere else (or it will take way longer). I've built a business on Play Store.
It's all about how you use them.
My bet’s on the latter. And so long as we all continue to support them (while claiming “but my boycott won’t do any good”), they’ll continue to use that financial support to ensure the continued non-involvement of the government in their affairs.
Doing nothing costs nothing, but it also changes nothing.
I quit Facebook along with most Google services, I feel much happier and more well adjusted than when I was using them. Meeting with family and friends is also much more interesting because I don't have a constant stream detailing their life.
Good luck petitioning the government to act on it... this goes double for US businesses and people who live outside the US.
Quality of life is not a binary, where you either 'have' it or not, so I don't think it makes sense to say "your quality of life DEPENDS on google or Facebook"
Many things make your quality of life a bit better, and some things make it a bit worse, but no one says they can't have a quality life without Facebook or google.
The person is saying that stopping using Facebook and google will slightly decrease their overall quality of life, but will have zero impact on Facebook and google.
Offhand the parent post would require me to give up Google Search (including via DDG), Gmail, Google Cloud, AWS, Amazon, Zappos, Audible, Comixology and Woot Shirts. I barely use Facebook or Twitter but the rest would lower my quality of life (and not just due to the large drop in employment opportunities I could take).
Petition the government if you like. It doesn't matter. You don't have millions to donate to the next campaign or their personal enrichment. You're not who they care about.
Quitting Facebook will objectively increase your quality of life.
--
"'It ate his head. Another loser.'
She said to the two of them, 'It's easy to win. Anybody can win.'"
-- A Scanner Darkly
Ask the government to do something about it? They're allies, they're in it together.
There is no scenario where they don't take out encryption this decade. It's a top priority and big tech is going to very happily assist them. Big tech will give them what they want, they will act as an arm of tyranny assisting the government in smashing human rights, and in return they'll get to continue to expand (they'll get a light touch regulatory treatment). It now has a lot in common with how China handles their giant corporations (so long as you do what we tell you to, you get to exist and thrive), and big tech in the US looks more like a CCP apparatus by the passing day.
All forms of expression and speech will continue to be restricted more by the passing year. The government won't need to do it themselves, big tech will do the dirty work with a wink and nod. That includes all app stores, all online content and forums, all software.
So, when you can't petition your government any longer because it's hell bent on taking your liberty away, what does that leave? The War on Domestic Terrorism of course. They'll create it, spur it, and then have an excuse to crack down on their own invention (not terribly different from how they ran the war on drugs). The US will be a horrible place to live in the near future. The foreign war on terrorism, in which the US did such unbelievable vicious things to other nations, will now turn inward, and the monster will come home, rolling over human rights as it goes.
If that's how it is where you live, and you live in a democracy, you can change that.
Switching from gmail to another provider isn't like living without electricity, it takes a couple of days updating some external accounts to reflect your new email; I did it.
Buying shit from somewhere that isn't Amazon isn't exactly trekking through the jungle for 3 weeks. All you have to do is type in another domain. There is no shortage of non-Amazon sellers with similar prices.
Switching from Chrome to Firefox takes 5 minutes, you can import your bookmarks and whatnot. Maybe you'll have to type in a password again. No climbing K2 level difficulty there either.
Android and iOS aren't that different, you can click a browser, camera, or email in either in the same amount of time with the same UI.
Sure it's effort, but it's not a hell of a lot of effort.
- LineageOS + MicroG and F-Droid for mobile.
- NextCloud (and DAV) running on an old laptop for calendar, contacts, and file storage. The mobile app uploads all my photos automatically. It backs up to Backblaze
-ProtonMail with a custom domain for email.
Amazon is pretty avoidable. Shipping has gotten faster and cheaper everywhere else at this point. At least for the rural place I am.
I'm not particularly tech savvy. This took a significant time effort for me. At this point, it's all pretty stable, I don't really have glitches anymore. I imagine the average HN user could easily replicate it, and if this type of setup got more popular, it would invariably get easier to set up.
Migrating email is intimidating, but alleviates the highest cost risk and is actually pretty painless. In my own case, I started a Fastmail account and told it to use my own domain and sync from my gmail account. I didn't have to commit to anything until I felt like it. After a couple of weeks I started lazily updating a few subscriptions as they got forwarded from gmail, and replying to people with 'hey, check it out this is my new email'. Now, Fastmail could vanish and I'd be temporarily inconvenienced for only as long as it took to staple my domain to some other email host. Losing access to my gmail account before making that switch would have been a disaster.
Why is that? I'm not being snarky, I just don't understand why.
The difference between a rooted and non-rooted android is like the being in the wheel group or sudoers file on unix/linux and not being in them.
Personally, I like to have full control of my own property.
What reason do you have for not wanting that?
We used yo have laws..
And opting out is literslly impossible, there are people and authorities i -have-to- communicate with, and its impossible outside those platforms
I stopped using these services and told people to contact me via sms or signal. No problems so far.
The people who won't make that extra step aren't worth my time because clearly I'm not worth their time.
- Make bank account.
- Bank forces you to use their app for obtaining TANs.
- App refuses to run because "your phone is rooted", i.e. because you removed Google's crap.
- No bank account for you, sorry bro.
I have personally been through this shit. Sure, some banks offer using a physical TAN generator - but not all!
There's nowhere to run away to.
You can, by pressuring politicians to create laws and regulations. It’s just something the US hasn’t tried all that much lately.