undefined | Better HN

0 pointsjsjohnst5y ago0 comments

Just to emphasize your point, 30% take is relatively small in the retail world. A store like Amazon or Walmart or Target or Best Buy generally wants a cut of 40-50%, if not more. And that doesn’t include the cut many distributors want to take for being the middle person.

(Source: I’ve been on the executive team at startups with products sold in retail stores)

0 comments

modo_mario5y ago

Then I'm sure you'd agree monopsonies due to increasing centralisation and clout in the past few decades aren't all that nice for the consumer and smaller players like startups.

donkeyd5y ago

Yup. And that excludes the fee many brands pay supermarkets to be in the eye level spot on the shelves. New entrants have to spend money just to be visible in the racks, regardless of whether their product is being sold.

webmobdev5y ago

> Just to emphasize your point, 30% take is relatively small in the retail world.

The internet already provides a nearly free distribution medium for software application - so even paying a 5% markup to an unnecessary middleman is just outrageous. The app store only exists so that Apple (and others) can gauge even more money from developers, who ultimately pass on the cost to us customers.

donkeyd5y ago

The web also allows any producer of physical products to distribute directly to consumers, doesn't it? So why is it OK for Amazon to get a fee, or any physical retailer? Aren't they unnecessary middle men too?

webmobdev5y ago

> So why is it OK for Amazon to get a fee, or any physical retailer? Aren't they unnecessary middle men too?

Amazon or Walmart or any other online or offline super market doesn't prevent either the manufacturer to sell directly to the consumer, or me as a consumer to directly buy from the producer / manufacturer.

Apple does precisely that with its restrictive app store on ios (and soon will on the macOS too), denying the buyer the right to buy an app directly from the developer and avoid the unnecessary burden of the Apple Tax. Due to this same restriction it is also able to charge the developer an annual recurring fee, again unnecessarily raising the total cost of an application for the user.

jsjohnstOP5y ago

And how does that dispute anything I said? I wasn’t making a claim that the AppStore commission is warranted or not, I was speaking to what retail stores charge. I get it, you think Apple is out of line, but maybe reply to someone who is claiming it’s justified rather than pointing your vitriol towards me?

webmobdev5y ago

I was bringing the debate back to what it was about, not "spewing vitriol" at you.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

modo_mario5y ago

Then I'm sure you'd agree monopsonies due to increasing centralisation and clout in the past few decades aren't all that nice for the consumer and smaller players like startups.

donkeyd5y ago

webmobdev5y ago

> Just to emphasize your point, 30% take is relatively small in the retail world.

donkeyd5y ago

webmobdev5y ago

> So why is it OK for Amazon to get a fee, or any physical retailer? Aren't they unnecessary middle men too?

jsjohnstOP5y ago

webmobdev5y ago

I was bringing the debate back to what it was about, not "spewing vitriol" at you.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse