undefined | Better HN

0 pointscurtis33895y ago0 comments

The common prefix is removed:

> Incidental white space surrounding the content, introduced to match the indentation of Java source code, is removed.

0 comments

8 comments · 2 top-level

hashhar5y ago· 6 in thread

I hate such kind of magic. Very convenient at first but can cause countless hours spent on debugging in some cases.

I like how Scala does this via the indent marker and strip.

e12e5y ago

I was going to answer gp "probably not" - but I would've been wrong. It looks to me like Java now has some of the most sophisticated in-line multi-line strings/here-documents that I'm aware of in any language. More details in:

https://openjdk.java.net/jeps/378

I'm not entirely sure "most sophisticated" is entirely a good thing - but the jep looks pretty thorough at least.

Ed: how does Scala do it? Java uses the indents for the closing triple-quote to determine stripping/indent + cutting trailing spaces. Ie, if my reading is correct:

  a = """
         OK.
      """

Is "OK.\n" (even if there are any spaces after the dot).

chadrs5y ago

At the string literal level doesn't do anything, but the standard library adds an extension method to string called `stripMargin`. This has some nice examples https://www.oreilly.com/library/view/scala-cookbook/97814493...

1 more reply

CydeWeys5y ago

It helps that Java is exclusively a compiled programming language, so these are just syntactic sugar concerns for the parser/lexer and the compiled bytecode ends up looking identical to having just used one long string with inline \n.

So given that, I don't think it really ends up being that sophisticated. I think this could be a decent easy programming question for a technical interview though!

dfinninger5y ago

I had to use this recently for an online course. It was super nice:

  def pushConstant(num: Int): String =
    s"""
       |@$num
       |D=A
       |$accessTopOfStack
       |M=D
       |$incrementStackPointer
       |""".stripMargin

accessTopOfStack and incrementStackPointer are other functions that return text. It made composing Assembly a breeze.

1 more reply

electrum5y ago

IntelliJ shows you exactly where the block starts, so if you have a line with less indentation (causing the entire block to start at that column), it is easy to spot.

hashhar5y ago

Thanks for sharing that. I can definitely see myself using the multi-line blocks since they are much better than the kind of things we need to do today.

At the same time I'm slightly scared of that magic. It helps that it's well-defined in the JEP.

jen205y ago

Thanks, quote much appreciated!

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

8 comments · 2 top-level

hashhar5y ago· 6 in thread

I hate such kind of magic. Very convenient at first but can cause countless hours spent on debugging in some cases.

I like how Scala does this via the indent marker and strip.

e12e5y ago

https://openjdk.java.net/jeps/378

I'm not entirely sure "most sophisticated" is entirely a good thing - but the jep looks pretty thorough at least.

Ed: how does Scala do it? Java uses the indents for the closing triple-quote to determine stripping/indent + cutting trailing spaces. Ie, if my reading is correct:

  a = """
         OK.
      """

Is "OK.\n" (even if there are any spaces after the dot).

chadrs5y ago

1 more reply

CydeWeys5y ago

So given that, I don't think it really ends up being that sophisticated. I think this could be a decent easy programming question for a technical interview though!

dfinninger5y ago

I had to use this recently for an online course. It was super nice:

  def pushConstant(num: Int): String =
    s"""
       |@$num
       |D=A
       |$accessTopOfStack
       |M=D
       |$incrementStackPointer
       |""".stripMargin

accessTopOfStack and incrementStackPointer are other functions that return text. It made composing Assembly a breeze.

1 more reply

electrum5y ago

IntelliJ shows you exactly where the block starts, so if you have a line with less indentation (causing the entire block to start at that column), it is easy to spot.

hashhar5y ago

Thanks for sharing that. I can definitely see myself using the multi-line blocks since they are much better than the kind of things we need to do today.

At the same time I'm slightly scared of that magic. It helps that it's well-defined in the JEP.

jen205y ago

Thanks, quote much appreciated!

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse