undefined | Better HN

0 pointsvikramkr5y ago0 comments

I got the impression that the complaint was more about the bribes and all than the regulations meant to protect the land

0 comments

3 comments · 1 top-level

danans5y ago· 2 in thread

I agree that the bribes are horrendous. But they're also what you get from a system that incentivizes corruption. You can't expect Indian bureaucracy to be like German bureaucracy, because the incentives are so different for the players at ground level.

The alternative is to pay public servants well and charge a very large fee for the permits to finance that. Then, deal corruption on top of that without impunity.

However, the culture itself has to support that. The culture of demanding bribes for documents shows that there's a parallel market in play to which the bureaucratic system has been subverted.

xfer5y ago

Public servants are paid well(if they get paid in time, some incompetent departments are failing their employees) along with amenities. So Bribery in india is mostly a cultural problem.

danans5y ago

> Public servants are paid well > So Bribery in india is mostly a cultural problem.

Apparently not well enough. When it's a few here and there you can argue that it's a character issue. When it's pervasive, there's a problem with the incentive structure.

I also wouldn't be so quick to condemn the culture, and I'm not so sure you can disentangle the cultural from the economic anyway.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse