undefined | Better HN

0 pointsransom15386y ago0 comments

Just running docker-compose on load balanced machines is pretty close to having all k8s features (that would give you an endpoint, scaling, running pods[containers],heartbeats and nodes[vms]). If you run Kubernetes on GCP you will see it's just a wrapper of GCP vms, load balancers, instance groups and disks. EG: GCP k8's autoscaling for the nodes isn't any better than just simple GCP load balancers and instance groups (it literally is the same thing). k8's best feature (only?): specify yaml files to declare the setup. That is great! But, you make edits to this 4 times a year - that is a ton of complexity for those 4 git commits.

0 comments

6 comments · 6 top-level

0xEFF6y ago

It’s pretty close to get it up and running. It’s not close to operating. You have to roll your own load balancer, health checks, method of updating and managing the underlying nodes, you don’t have operators or guarantees about the control plane, etc...

Spin up a K8S in any major cloud provider and you get all this with a consistent API, which is where the value lies.

1 more reply

ec1096856y ago

With Kubernetes, you can run multiple apps in the same cluster and let Kubernetes manage the capacity on GCP for you. Nice this you have shared headroom for all your apps versus an app per VM in your setup (I think?).

What is wrong with actually using Google’s hosted Kubernetes that would make you want to run compose yourself in their VMs and setup auto scaling, physical machine upgrades, etc.

banifo6y ago

You can replicate k8s featureset with plenty of other architectures.

But thats not the point.

k8s is the first infrastructure control plane in existence which is widley supported and standardized.

Can you get a managed docker swarm on aws, gcp, azure, do etc.? no.

How many kubernetes offerings do you know? I know at least 6.

Revolution doesn't need to be flashy and noisy.

crymer116y ago

Off the top of my head, deployments and sidecars are both missing, which are incredibly useful.

3 more replies

marktolson6y ago

We edit yaml files everytime we update a service version, which happens multiple times per week? Is there a better way to deal with this?

1 more reply

rfks6y ago

GKE uses other GCP products, but ”k8's autoscaling for the nodes isn't any better than just simple GCP load balancers and instance groups (it literally is the same thing)” isn't entirely accurate - GKE and K8S have logic that manages node pools that you won't be able to use with just instance groups.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse