undefined | Better HN

0 pointsCountSessine15y ago0 comments

Yeah, why not? Among top tier laptop and cellphone manufacturers, the only name that appears on both lists is Apple (well, I guess Samsung makes laptops too...). Adding a SIM/RUIM slot and a 3G chip makes so much sense. I know a lot of laptop manufacturers in Europe have offered this as an option. Why not Apple?

0 comments

8 comments · 3 top-level

samatman15y ago· 3 in thread

Because it's more profitable for Apple if you get your 3G from a tethered iPhone?

Splines15y ago

Maybe more profitable for AT&T. It's not like you're not going to buy an iPhone because they add 3G to their laptops.

kooshball15y ago

why would it be tethering be profitable for Apple? AFAIK they do not get a cut of the tethering charge from providers.

sandyc15y ago

Because then you have to buy an iPhone (and proprietary cables, and then you might find some fun apps etc.)

danudey15y ago· 2 in thread

Because most people don't want to pay for two 3G data plans, and the types of people who would want 3G connectivity on their laptops probably have 3G smartphones with tethering already.

ugh15y ago

You don’t have to pay for a data plan. I use one of those prepaid 3G USB sticks and pay 2.50€ for one day unlimited HSDPA internet access (limited to GPRS speeds after 500MB).

That’s perfect for me since I’m maybe six hours in a train two or three times a month and no flatrate can beat the five or eight Euro I’m paying.

There are dozens of other options available (at least in Germany), suitable for pretty much any conceivable need and some will come with extra SIM cards for your smartphone or tablet.

How about this one: 15€ per month, unlimited HSDPA internet access (limited to GPRS speeds after 1GB), 9ct per minute for all phone calls and SMS (as always in Europe, incoming phone calls and SMS are free), two SIM cards. You could order an unlocked iPhone from Apple right now (I don’t know whether that’s possible in the US but it is now in Germany) and put one SIM card in the phone and use the other one for your laptop or whatever other device.

danudey15y ago

In the US and Canada you don't get anything like these offers, and Apple's not the kind to redesign their hardware just so that some people in Europe can do something easily accomplished with a smartphone or a $50-100 USB 3G modem.

1 more reply

tomkarlo15y ago

Maybe they're not confident that the number of people choosing this option would compensate for the extra training and infrastructure necessary to support it, plus the tie-ins with a carrier. It's one thing to do that for the iPhone where every customer wants it, another for 5% of Macbook buyers.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse