undefined | Better HN

0 pointscapableweb6y ago0 comments

> A large majority of people who use Slack disagree with you

How do you know? Most people I know, uses Slack because that's the company policy, not because they find Slack the best option. But I don't think that's the majority of people, because is just my biased view, but probably it's the same in your case.

0 comments

6 comments · 2 top-level

ajkjk6y ago· 4 in thread

I have... never met anyone in real life who doesn't like slack. I only hear negative opinions about it here.

gumby6y ago

> I have... never met anyone in real life who doesn't like slack. I only hear negative opinions about it here.

While I have literal never discussed Slack with someone who likes it. Actually not completely true: at my last company one developer thought it was great but after a few months I heard her curse it as a "place information goes to die". In my experience it doesn't scale beyond a very small number of people who know each other well. Sending commands from its command line is not as easy as simply sending them from, you know, the command line (which is scriptable).

As a side point it astonishes me that after all the money they raised and people they hired they can't get video working on mobile, just laptop/desktop.

Swizec6y ago

I love Slack. It’s also where information goes to die. You’re not supposed to keep permanent info in a chat room.

You could say the same thing about meetings — they’re where information goes to die. Because a meeting (which is what Slack is) isn’t meant to store information, it’s meant to discuss information.

komali26y ago

Come grab a coffee with me, I'm at 2nd and Howard, about a block away from the Slack office. Or just hang near the sidewalk, our windows are open and at some point my whinging about slack (or gitlab) should float down to the sidewalk.

marblar6y ago

This can't be true. I work on that block and haven't heard you.

blackandblue6y ago

slack and confluence :)

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse