undefined | Better HN

0 pointsrefurb6y ago0 comments

FDA has done research into it and it clearly provides some value.

Other highlights of the surveys include:

Most physicians agreed that because their patient saw a DTC ad, he or she asked thoughtful questions during the visit. About the same percentage of physicians thought the ad made their patients more aware of possible treatments.

Many physicians thought that DTC ads made their patients more involved in their health care.

https://www.fda.gov/drugs/drug-information-consumers/impact-...

0 comments

monadic26y ago

I would imagine you’d need to draw a correlation between advertisements and quality of care and successful treatment rate; awareness and involvement aren’t positive or negative per se.

Secondly, I see too many damn branded pens in my doctor’s office to be under the illusion that the marketing is only directed at the patients. I can’t count the number of times I’ve been prescribed medication just to have it swapped out at the pharmacy for a generic variety. Doctors are just as susceptible to advertising than the rest of us, except exclusively at harm to the patient.

The demonstrated “value” being provided seems to be mostly in the form of cash in the pockets of providers and pharmaceuticals, not in material benefit to the patients.

mikestew6y ago

Secondly, I see too many damn branded pens in my doctor’s office to be under the illusion that the marketing is only directed at the patients.

I can assure you that drug reps didn't bring in catered lunch to my ex-wife's GP office for the benefit of better informing patients about their choices. We got divorced 30 years ago, but I'd bet money I've still got a sticky note pad lying around the house somewhere with a pharma company's name on it.

There's plenty of drug marketing going on that will never come under the gaze of a patient.

tialaramex6y ago

So, the reason they've got branded pens is that the drug reps are allowed to give them pens, so they do. Trivial low value gift. Historically the doctor wouldn't remember HealthyHeart brand beta blockers because of the 40 cent pen but because they paid for his two week safari. Most of the world banned that, but not so very long ago. My nurse friend didn't spend a penny of her own money on big birthday events when she was younger, drug reps paid for everything. (In the NHS system some nurses have full prescribing powers I presume some US nurses likewise but even if not it's the same for doctors)

aladoc996y ago

Drug reps in the US quit giving away pens and coffee mugs in the US in 2008, in accord with PhRMA rules (that's the drug manufacturers' association/lobby). They got to say it was improved ethics, but it was also a mutual disarmament agreement of sorts. "We'll stop giving out sticky pads if you will."

adamsea6y ago

If the true goal is to educate the patient, I'm 100% certain there are more effective and ethical ways to accomplish that goal other than for-profit advertising (which by definition cannot be unbiased).

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse