undefined | Better HN

0 pointsSpooky236y ago0 comments

The difference here is that Microsoft is bypassing existing user consent mechanisms of their own making, and repeatedly disrespecting user choice.

If as a user, you change back to DuckDuckGo, your next Office patch cycle will “re-Bing” you in a month.

Google Chrome does not do that. If you express your intent to use another search provider, it sticks. Likewise, there is a clear and reliable way to make that choice via policy. This Bing thing has a convoluted and unreliable workaround.

0 comments

5 comments · 2 top-level

bishalb6y ago· 2 in thread

Does a user who installs Chrome provide consent for Google to be their default search engine?

Spooky23OP6y ago

Yes.

It’s part of the as built configuration of the browser. Just like how Bing is the default for Edge, or Google for Safari.

It’s a design choice that has become a de facto standard, as nobody wants to wade through an onboarding questionnaire for your browser.

This is different, it’s modifying an as-configured configuration and linking it to the update process. It’s bad, as we should be able to trust update processes to be as minimally disruptive as possible.

silicon24016y ago

if you don't consent, don't download

lonelappde6y ago· 1 in thread

> If as a user, you change back to DuckDuckGo, your next Office patch cycle will “re-Bing” you in a month.

Is this verified?

Spooky23OP6y ago

It’s in Microsoft’s documentation as of right now. You don’t really know until they do it, as Microsoft doesn’t necessarily do what they document.

> Version 2002 is the first version of Office 365 ProPlus that will install this extension. Version 2002 is expected to be released in Monthly Channel in early March 2020 and will be available in Monthly Channel (Targeted) shortly before then. After that, the extension will then be included in releases of Semi-Annual (Targeted) and Semi-Annual Channel.

https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/deployoffice/microsoft-sear...

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse