Ask HN: Commuter Bicycle for City?

If I were you I wouldn't look for a brand explicitly... I'd follow craigslist for bikes that are a good deal.

I got my Trek commuter for $120 (originally $550). People have a tendency to buy things like bikes thinking that they'll use them more than they do (Like those people that buy a guitar so they'll learn to play), a year or two later they end up just selling them to get more space.

Just a thought.

Curious what city you're commuting in though.

Good on you for both your intention to commute by bike as well as your thoughtful consideration of what bike. I commuted for four years a ride very similar to what you are faced with. Mine was 11 miles each way pretty flat though. I used a somewhat uncommon Bridgetown X-03 hardtail bike which they referred to as a commuter bike when I bought it and I still like it for that. it’s got larger tires but no shocks up front or in back. With 21 gears it’s obviously a little overkill for a relatively flat route but it’s nice to be able to find the gear that is perfect for your conditions. I agree with the safety gear recommendations, however, I do use a flashing headlight in daylight conditions I don’t use it flashing at night in daylight i use flashing headlight and flashing red tail light I use that all the way up to dusk and then turn the headlight on once it actually gets dark or as close to dark. A vest or a light colored shirt is good as are reflective tags on bike, helmet and shoes. Be noticed, be safe. Wear clothing that allows you to ventilate well as you warm up. Clips for your pedals are nice if you don’t have too many stops along the way. I recommend puncture resistant tires and tubes, too.

When was the last time you rode? How far? What kind of bike?

The type of bike and the brand of bike don't really matter -- you need a bike you will ride. Does it fit? Do you enjoy riding.

I moved a couple of years ago; but, prior to that, I commuted year-round by bike. (10 miles one way) I rode a hard tail mountain bike -- that was the bike I felt the most comfortable riding in traffic, construction zones, etc. (I had several other bikes, including a recumbent.) Most of the other bike commuters I knew rode road bikes, except for a couple who rode recumbents. It really comes down to what you feel comfortable riding; so, you enjoy riding it, twice a day, every day, in sunshine and in rain.

Consider picking up a used bike first. jppope's Craigslist suggestion is good. Also check your local bike shop, since some have used bikes. Even Goodwill might be an option. See if you really like commuting by bike. If you do, get a nicer back and you have a backup.

Get a reflective vest and wear it. A taillight is better than a rear reflector. Get a good, strong headlight, especially if you are riding at dawn, dusk, or night. You'll use it in the rain, too. Do not get a flashing headlight.

Keep at it and don't get discouraged. It's a great way to commute.

If your city has a bike share, try it out for a little while. The convenience of being able to drop off or pick up a bike anywhere is worth the clunkiness of bike share bikes for me.