undefined | Better HN

0 pointsdavesmith19836y ago0 comments

The categorisation you are trying to make us accept is ridiculous.

I can deploy a python web application I have written to a new web server within minutes by clicking deploy in bitbucket.

So using your definition:

* The code is already written.

* I clicked a few menus and I had the python code I wanted running.

It isn't a python application. However the web application when it receives a request will run python code. It is clearly a python based web application.

0 comments

rowanG0776y ago

I wouldn't consider it python code if it is a cookie cutter website where the creator didn't have to write a single line of python. It's not about deployment it's about the process of creation. Why don't you consider each and every website running PHP also a C website?

davesmith1983OP6y ago

> I wouldn't consider it python code if it is a cookie cutter website where the creator didn't have to write a single line of python.

So if I got someone else to press the deploy button in bitbucket, it suddenly isn't python code? That doesn't make sense does it?

> Why don't you consider each and every website running PHP also a C website?

The web site/app logic is written in PHP, not C. The runtime for the vast majority of PHP deployments happens to be written in C.

Additionally while I did say interpreted earlier that really isn't true anymore. PHP runtimes these days tend to break the PHP script down into byte-code. There are alternative runtimes for PHP just as there is Java or .NET.

There are at least 4 I can think of. Two of those aren't C (C++ and .NET). However there is nothing stopping you from writing a runtime that runs on the JVM / Lisp / Go / Brainfuck / Lol code / 68k assembler.

rowanG0776y ago

> So if I got someone else to press the deploy button in bitbucket, it suddenly isn't python code? That doesn't make sense does it?

You completely ignored the most important sentence in my comment which addresses this.

> The web site/app logic is written in PHP, not C. The runtime for the vast majority of PHP deployments happens to be written in C.

The logic is written in PHP just as much as it is written in C. The logic is actually written in the language the creator used. Which is the wordpress UI.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsdavesmith19836y ago0 comments

The categorisation you are trying to make us accept is ridiculous.

I can deploy a python web application I have written to a new web server within minutes by clicking deploy in bitbucket.

So using your definition:

* The code is already written.

* I clicked a few menus and I had the python code I wanted running.

It isn't a python application. However the web application when it receives a request will run python code. It is clearly a python based web application.

0 comments

rowanG0776y ago

davesmith1983OP6y ago

> I wouldn't consider it python code if it is a cookie cutter website where the creator didn't have to write a single line of python.

So if I got someone else to press the deploy button in bitbucket, it suddenly isn't python code? That doesn't make sense does it?

> Why don't you consider each and every website running PHP also a C website?

The web site/app logic is written in PHP, not C. The runtime for the vast majority of PHP deployments happens to be written in C.

rowanG0776y ago

> So if I got someone else to press the deploy button in bitbucket, it suddenly isn't python code? That doesn't make sense does it?

You completely ignored the most important sentence in my comment which addresses this.

> The web site/app logic is written in PHP, not C. The runtime for the vast majority of PHP deployments happens to be written in C.

The logic is written in PHP just as much as it is written in C. The logic is actually written in the language the creator used. Which is the wordpress UI.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse