undefined | Better HN

0 pointssocialist_coder6y ago0 comments

I would disagree with that. When you ban someone, they know. They make a new account and come back.

When you move them to a cheater queue, they don't know. They keep playing, none the wiser. It's infinitely better for everyone. The cheater still gets to play, and the non-cheaters aren't affected as much because the cheater doesn't just keep coming back.

The complexity in your app is that you need to have multiple matchmaking queues, which you probably already support due to skill tiers. So is it really that difficult to add more matchmaking queues for the cheaters?

0 comments

2 comments · 2 top-level

afiori6y ago

But it is more complex in the sense that you need a lot of fine tuning. If you just match cheaters with cheaters then it is easy to see too.

You need some kind of dynamic ranking of "toxicity" (in this case cheating) match user with other of similar toxicity.

pingyong6y ago

>When you move them to a cheater queue, they don't know. They keep playing, none the wiser.

When 99.9% of the people you get matched with are cheaters (many of which might be quite obvious), it's not that hard to figure out that your account was probably shadow banned. Some cheaters might not care, but it's certainly not hard to figure out.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse