undefined | Better HN

0 pointssago6y ago0 comments

Can you say more what you mean by 'doesn't suffice'? There are certainly some forms of typographic initial I know it can't do. But if it worked consistently, it would be sufficient to achieve the effect that the article is attempting, wouldn't it?

Thanks for the link. I had no idea it was an active proposal.

0 comments

gsnedders6y ago

Without knowledge of the fonts used, you can't get both ascender line and baseline aligned with respective lines of content, which is the traditional way of doing drop caps.

Sure, with web fonts and assumptions that the font always successfully loads and covers all graphemes in the text you can hardcode lengths to achieve proper alignment, but that's still a bit fragile.

DougBTX6y ago

The implementation in the article still used hard-coded lengths, perhaps this could have been fixed without the extra markup after all.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

gsnedders6y ago

Without knowledge of the fonts used, you can't get both ascender line and baseline aligned with respective lines of content, which is the traditional way of doing drop caps.

Sure, with web fonts and assumptions that the font always successfully loads and covers all graphemes in the text you can hardcode lengths to achieve proper alignment, but that's still a bit fragile.

DougBTX6y ago

The implementation in the article still used hard-coded lengths, perhaps this could have been fixed without the extra markup after all.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse