undefined | Better HN

0 pointsricardobeat7y ago0 comments

> libraries like React would be optional/redundant when custom components are involved (like in complex web apps)

This is where we disagree - this is not true at all. In complex web apps, what you need the most is high-level components such as `<BlogArticle>` that allow you to tame complexity, isolate reusable pieces of UI that might be as large as a page itself, and not just localized elements. As you acknowledge, WC doesn't even aspire to fill this role, meaning you'll still need higher level frameworks on top of them, which significantly diminishes the value of being built-in.

0 comments

1 comments · 1 top-level

TimTheTinker7y ago

Have you ever tried to build a reusable multi-select combo box? That’s not easy without some framework. Event and state management can become a real headache.

But higher-level items like articles/comments are so much easier without a framework - I just don’t see how React/etc. is necessary given you have a decent templating library and a module loader that has CSS, JSON, and string plugins.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse