undefined | Better HN

0 pointsfock6y ago0 comments

Oh yeah I get that you are not comparing with anything else, because then your criticism wouldn't be on matrix but on how about 99% of the internet today work _by design_. With any protocol, where you are expecting any reliable, low-latency 2-way communication, each partner will know about the other, you won't work around that anytime soon. What you can work around is the number/mass of the partner which is acting as your always-on messaging relay, eventually trading convenience for privacy - I agree that vector/riot is not looking too good on this, but I don't see how they're not clear on it/working towards eventual resolution of this problems. One can argue whether this should be the first priority or an afterthought but I've grudgingly accepted the latter being standard today (just look at all those leaky SaaS-apps on hn...).

For the perception/expectations of average Joe on privacy/obscurity on the internet I recommend you read the recurring threads on any platform whenever there is a new "scandal" centered on whatsapp (europe): half of your commenters will just tell you that they are gonna use Telegram (yeah, the ones, where you don't know exactly whose behind and which think that encrypted group chat is too much of a hassle).

Regarding your comments that the protocol is broken, I'm really surprised how you are intending to tackle this? Why the hell are you using the very same protocol which is driven by a body which you claim intransparent and non-cooperative? If all your allegiations are true you would have been better of rolling your own/your software won't be compatible for long if you take your own writing seriously...

P.S.: care to elaborate who's "we"? Your projects have a surprisingly low number of contributors (which hopefully changes now), so I can't really figure out, why you are not just saying "I". Also don't know what's so bad on taking a stand in a civilized public discussion (if "we" decided to be anonymous)?

0 comments

9935c101ab17a666y ago

> Oh yeah I get that you are not comparing with anything else, because then your criticism wouldn't be on matrix but on how about 99% of the internet today work _by design_.

You want to quite a length to work in this irrelevant slight.

I don't know enough about the design/implementation and the overall context to add anything of technical value to conversation and I won't even try. I would, however, like to point out that both your 'tone' and 'demeanour' come across as incredibly hostile and unnecessarily personal.

Also, dismissing a possibly valid criticism or review of something because it doesn't present immediate solutions to the problems highlighted doesn't mean the criticism itself has no worth, and to discount it out of hand for this reason is folly.

fockOP6y ago

The P.S. is unnecessarily personal, I won't edit it but hereby apologize for the harsh tone.

Other than that I suppose this is personal, since this seems to be the personal pet project of the author (and he constantly assumes a "we" as if multiple people were signing his rant).

And if you read my comments carefully, I never critizise the lack of solutions. My critic relies on the fact that he starts with very clickbaity "facts" which are then elaborated assuming that average joe is running his own homeserver and not knowing the tradeoffs of it. He then happily mixes up problems of any non-TOR messenger (of which matrix.org matrix is one...) and specific problems of running a matrix-homeserver with the recommended settings, using the vector.im phonebook (and apparently a bunch of these settings are bugs...).

Such as it stands, this is convoluted FUD. If he wanted to make a constructive contribution he might as well have stated the problems upfront (the current working matrix implementation relies on proprietary/centralized services) and then gone into a discussion of every problem step-by-step (and advertizing the very solutions he tries to sell). The problems of matrix/vector/riot are as real as Mozilla pivoting to the Firefox Service Company and integrating a host of proprietary tools, but the problem has deserved better than this rant...

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse