undefined | Better HN

0 pointsderekp77y ago0 comments

Are mortgages really debt though? Because even though you owe, you also own as much as you owe (except during a market downturn of course). Whereas debt for a depreciating asset (like a car, or most things that go on a credit card) are what I would consider "real" debt. In other words, keep your net debt low or non existent (when looking at a balance sheet).

0 comments

10 comments · 6 top-level

burlesona7y ago· 2 in thread

If you owned a house in 2008, I assure you, you'd feel that your mortgage was real debt.

Or if you ever got laid off.

Or if you ever got injured or severely sick and found yourself with shocking hospital bills.

When life hits you with something like that, suddenly that monthly payment, and the risk of foreclosure, bankruptcy, and severely damaged credit, all looms large over your head like the Sword of Damocles.

Yes a mortgage is real debt.

pm907y ago

Sure, but most people who do take on mortgages do just fine. There will be exceptions but on the average, taking on mortgage to purchase a home in the US is generally a safe bet.

nightski7y ago

The majority of what you said is true of renting also.

pmoriarty7y ago· 1 in thread

"Are mortgages really debt though? Because even though you owe, you also own as much as you owe (except during a market downturn of course)."

You also pay interest, which could be a huge amount (depending on how quickly, if ever, you pay off your principal).

derekp7OP7y ago

The interest though isn't debt -- as soon as you sell the property, you only owe at that time the remaining balance, not the total amount of interest you would pay. In other words, interest is what you pay to rent the money used to buy the house.

moorhosj7y ago· 1 in thread

==Because even though you owe, you also own as much as you owe (except during a market downturn of course).==

Do you own that much? Let's put some real numbers on this. You buy a $350k house, and put down $70k (20%). That leaves you with a $280k mortgage at 4%. This gives you a monthly mortgage payment of $1,337.

If you pay that monthly, you would own 51% of the house ($175k of equity) some time in the 16th year of your mortgage. After making 188 mortgage payments. Note, this doesn't include housing value appreciation.

COST

20% down - $70k

mortgage payments ($1,337 * 188) - $251,356

sk5t7y ago

I suspect the parent is talking about leverage; and, your view of cumulative mortgage payments ignored the time value of money.

astura7y ago

Yes, they certainly are a debt, but they are, in general, considered a "good debt." Educational debt and business startup debt are also, in general, considered "good debt."

https://www.investopedia.com/articles/pf/12/good-debt-bad-de...

That being said, it's a general statement, specific cases of those can be "bad debts" if they are taken out recklessly and/or without forethought and planning and budgeting.

ska7y ago

Of course it's debt. But it is secured debt, which is a bit of different risk profile.

Never forget though, you are paying quite a bit for the use of that money (i.e. the banks). This is mitigated in a rising market, but lots of houses (well land, really) don't appreciate fast enough to counter this.

Not to mention the additional costs. It might be more accurate to think of your house as a depreciating asset (the house) bundled with a (hopefully) appreciated asset (the land it is on)

wonderwonder7y ago

Sure, you pay interest on the loan. By the time the loan is paid off you have generally paid well in excess of the original loan amount back to the lender. Borrow 100k at 4% for 30 years and at the end you have paid $171,870. Maybe the home appreciates at the same rate, maybe not. You are right in that it is better than credit card debt my a mile though.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse