Ask HN: App for finding your cognitive siblings?

13 pointsmjhirn7y ago14 comments

Hey HN,

I have this idea: An app that lets you find your 'cognitive siblings' - people that share your viewpoints, interests, etc. based on (a subset of) your browsing history.

Would like to see if this is something worth building a prototype for.

Facebook, but for connecting with people that you haven't met yet. Twitter, but finding also 'non-famous' cognitive siblings.

The idea is a plugin, that records your browsing history and shows you people with similar histories that you can then connect with.

Do you think that would produce interesting sibling results? Why / Why not? Has it been attempted before - why didn't it work out? (Maybe leaving privacy issues aside here for now)

14 comments

agitator7y ago

I think this is a pretty interesting idea.

Someone mentioned why not just follow subreddits. I noticed that subreddits are often a collection of the extremes of a hobby or interest. I would say that I'm a collection of interest that make up my unique personality, while subreddits often have people that are really deep into a specific topic.

One thing to note about your idea, is I've used apps in the past that connect you with people that you share interest with, but I often flake when it comes to actually meeting with people in person... I wonder if this is a common trend? I feel like I almost ended up using them as a self validation.... but never followed through much with meeting people.

mjhirnOP7y ago

Hearing friends talking about flaking, I would say it is a very common theme. I would also think, that you may not want to meet up with that person, because either not in the same city, or because you may match with a lot of different people which also may change over time.

I also thought of it more like a self-validation thing, a source of more information, recommendations, etc. What you would get back may be an online conversation or a feed of relevant websites.

qnsi7y ago

What are examples of apps that connect you with people with similar interests? I mean, not dating, right?

snazz7y ago

I like the browsing history concept, because browsing and search history really delves deep into who someone is, but you might get a more accurate image of someone’s real-life self by using an interests questionnaire alongside or in place of browsing history to better see the offline interests someone has.

For instance, I really like cycling, but my programming-related Google searches eclipse my cycling-related ones by a huge margin, so your hypothetical algorithm would rank programming as a much greater interest than cycling, even if I spend about equal amounts of time on each.

rboyd7y ago

Connecting with similar people would be good.

Getting relevant link recommendations would be great.

Similar ideas: delicious, prismatic, StumbleUpon.

Biggest issues are probably chicken-and-egg problem and privacy concerns.

arandr0x7y ago

The idea is to have a conversation with someone who's read as much of the same things you have as possible? What do you learn from this?

Regardsyjc7y ago

I read a lot but there aren't many people I know who read the same things I do- so I am unable to have deeper conversations about the things I read. Everyone adds something, their own meaning and context so they can see something you're not able to.

Do you agree or disagree? What did you think about this point? It reminded me of this instance. Have you also read that instance, do you agree? Etc.

mjhirnOP7y ago

Good question! Could see that a conversation with that person may go very stale very quickly, but may have some other benefits?

- Great reading recommendations

- Great proof-of-competence like a 'badge' or 'degree' when hiring

omosubi7y ago

there's plenty to discuss whenever you've read something someone else has read. just think about book clubs that get together and talk about books that everyone has just read based on questions that they might have shared before hand. you can always share your insights into the book, your opinions on the content, connections to other things, etc. It's funny to me that people are saying that conversations around these things would get stale.

My tip would be to have a group of friends, potentially online in a group chat or in person, all read one or two _short_ pieces that you have selected so you can discuss them, and then have another person select pieces, etc. I highly doubt that you will find another person out in the ether that has read a lot of the same stuff as you have at the level you want or expect.

ATLB14117y ago

Why not just go on reddit and look for subreddits you are interested in, to find these like minded people?

kazinator7y ago

Because you somehow have to ferret out the ones who recur on many of those subreddits. "Oh look, bob123 is a regular on seven out of the nine subs! My cognitive sibling"

natmaka7y ago

In any case such a tool may warn the user against its potential echo chamber effect.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Echo_chamber_%28media%29

hluska7y ago

This would either be a very good or very bad dating site. I'd like to be positive and say very good, but I've been online long enough to have concerns...:)

kspy7y ago

Wonder if spotify will ever release something like this as a feature

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

14 comments

agitator7y ago

I think this is a pretty interesting idea.

mjhirnOP7y ago

I also thought of it more like a self-validation thing, a source of more information, recommendations, etc. What you would get back may be an online conversation or a feed of relevant websites.

qnsi7y ago

What are examples of apps that connect you with people with similar interests? I mean, not dating, right?

snazz7y ago

rboyd7y ago

Connecting with similar people would be good.

Getting relevant link recommendations would be great.

Similar ideas: delicious, prismatic, StumbleUpon.

Biggest issues are probably chicken-and-egg problem and privacy concerns.

arandr0x7y ago

The idea is to have a conversation with someone who's read as much of the same things you have as possible? What do you learn from this?

Regardsyjc7y ago

Do you agree or disagree? What did you think about this point? It reminded me of this instance. Have you also read that instance, do you agree? Etc.

mjhirnOP7y ago

Good question! Could see that a conversation with that person may go very stale very quickly, but may have some other benefits?

- Great reading recommendations

- Great proof-of-competence like a 'badge' or 'degree' when hiring

omosubi7y ago

ATLB14117y ago

Why not just go on reddit and look for subreddits you are interested in, to find these like minded people?

kazinator7y ago

Because you somehow have to ferret out the ones who recur on many of those subreddits. "Oh look, bob123 is a regular on seven out of the nine subs! My cognitive sibling"

natmaka7y ago

In any case such a tool may warn the user against its potential echo chamber effect.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Echo_chamber_%28media%29

hluska7y ago

This would either be a very good or very bad dating site. I'd like to be positive and say very good, but I've been online long enough to have concerns...:)

kspy7y ago

Wonder if spotify will ever release something like this as a feature

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse