undefined | Better HN

Skip to content

Top Best Ask Show New Jobs

0 pointsJasber8y ago0 comments

Didn't this come up with TiVo commercial skipping? The issue was with TiVo, the customer never even had a chance to see the ad, not that ads are mandatory to watch. Doesn't that apply here?

0 comments

5 comments · 2 top-level

bglusman8y ago· 3 in thread

Do you mean ReplayTV? I owned a Tivo at some point but replayTV was great because it auto-detected ads and had an option (or default behavior?) of skipping them automatically. Tivo you had to manually push 30 second skip 6 times.

__david__8y ago

TiVo currently has an ad-detecting feature. You used to have to fast forward through the ads (though at 30x speed that just took a few seconds). Now it's still not automatic, but when the commercial break comes you press channel up once and it skips perfectly to the end of the break. It's now almost as good as torrenting!

JasberOP8y ago

I think the original TiVo's had this "auto-skip" feature but had to be removed due to this issue.

ryan-c8y ago

TiVo had a 30 second skip feature to make manually skipping ads easy that they "disabled" (there was a "cheat code" to turn it back on) to avoid legal issues. They also had a button to skip 8 seconds back, but that was far easier to justify.

With some shows viewable with comcast they disable fast forward.

Ok that might be acceptable (even though the person was payin over 200 a month)

Heres whats really not ok:

I fat fingered the remote and pressed restart. Now i cant fast forward through any of the commercials OR the program i was 20 minutes into.

We shut the tv off

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse