undefined | Better HN

0 pointsAloha8y ago0 comments

Everyone keeps saying that EV's are a huge paradigm shift, but they don't explain how - in the end its a car - and not much more inherently high tech than many other cars - replacing the method of propulsion, does not fundamentally alter how you build it, or how you source the parts to build it.

0 comments

mschuster918y ago

> replacing the method of propulsion, does not fundamentally alter how you build it, or how you source the parts to build it.

There are fundamental changes in car design. No need for a huge tunnel and axle in RWD cars, and no huge, loud, hot and vibrating engine in the front. In addition the battery pack shifts down the centre of gravity (thus making the car way better in handling curves), and the now free space in the front (what Tesla calls "frunk") is a huge crumple zone.

Also, with the engine there goes a huge complex part with many different highly specialized suppliers - granted, it's replaced by another set of parts, but fundamentally it's orders of magnitude less parts, and easier to install.

AlohaOP8y ago

It's a big change - but neither fundamental or a paradigm shift.

I replace one set of complimented parts from specialized suppliers, with another set, we've had flat panned cars before, both rear engined, and front wheel drive, both the Corvair and the Beetle had a frunk, and the Prius has a big heavy battery under the floor, changing the center or gravity.

I'm not downplaying the significance of the technology, but its a evolutionary development, of early electric cars, rather than a sea change.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse