undefined | Better HN

0 pointsChromozon8y ago0 comments

This is a great example of how many of the things in C that don't compile in C++ are horrible programming practices, and it's really nice that C++ doesn't allow such garbage.

0 comments

magnusjonsson8y ago

Actually those are very bad examples. In practice, compilers will produce warnings in all of those examples.

Better examples (of actually useful things) would be things like designated initializers, struct literals, declaring array lengths in args using static, etc.

milesrout8y ago

I don't see what is 'horrible programming practice' about

    int *x = malloc(sizeof(int));

maccard8y ago

because malloc doesn't return an int, it returns a void

milesrout8y ago

malloc returns a void pointer because it implicitly converts to an int pointer, as it should.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

magnusjonsson8y ago

Actually those are very bad examples. In practice, compilers will produce warnings in all of those examples.

Better examples (of actually useful things) would be things like designated initializers, struct literals, declaring array lengths in args using static, etc.

milesrout8y ago

I don't see what is 'horrible programming practice' about

    int *x = malloc(sizeof(int));

maccard8y ago

because malloc doesn't return an int, it returns a void

milesrout8y ago

malloc returns a void pointer because it implicitly converts to an int pointer, as it should.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse