undefined | Better HN

0 pointsdigitalengineer9y ago0 comments

It's about all user intent. Will you bring value? For you I'd advice experimenting with a pop-up when the user is about to leave. "A popup designed with exit-intent – in laymans terms it means that the popup only displays when you are about to leave the site." Results? "an increase of sign-ups by 600%. They went from typically 70-80 daily new subscribers to 445 – 470 new subs per day."

0 comments

bradleyankrom9y ago

How would you go about detecting when a user is about to leave your site? Other than responding to a click on an external link? The two ways I typically leave a site are a) typing a URL into the address bar and b) closing a tab.

gjm119y ago

Well, if the user is like me then having just put up a big content-obscuring popup is an excellent sign that the user is about to leave.

bradleyankrom9y ago

Thanks for the answers, everyone. I was mostly curious to see if the technique was to pause the page unload or something when the user tried to go to a different site (a dark pattern, IMO). I don't personally object to the cursor location and page scrolling techniques mentioned here.

Nadya9y ago

Watch for the mouse along the upper 10px of the window [0] or use of the [Ctrl] key (for Ctrl+L or Ctrl+W). Or as other said, for a threshold of upper/upper-left mouse movement.

You'll get a few false flags from people trying to Ctrl+C but so many people use the right-click context menu to copy/paste...you can probably ignore Ctrl+_ entirely and just focus on that window near the top. Most users will pass by that area when going to:

    1) Change to another tab
    2) Close the tab
    3) Type a new search/website in the Omnibar

[0] http://i.imgur.com/ihiAcHe.png

JimDabell9y ago

That's really irritating because you get false positives (not "false flag", that's something else entirely) whenever you go to change tabs with the mouse.

If somebody is interested in subscribing, then a subscribe box at the bottom or side of the content is fine.

1 more reply

digitalengineerOP9y ago

Most people move to the left and up ;-) (Basically to the back button). See: http://optinmonster.com/how-it-works/ (WARNING: POP-UP! Ha ha

Lxr9y ago

Scrolling up seems pretty popular. Why wouldn't you want a half-page menu telling you what to read next when you scroll up to check something?

GrinningFool9y ago

Why would you? You're not scrolling up to get recommendations, you're scrolling up to re-read content.

Or at least, that's me. If I want to go back to navigation, I hit the Home key (the vast majority of systems do have one or two of them...). If I'm scrolling up, it's to read.

csallen9y ago

It's typically done when the user's mouse leaves the page.

eric_h9y ago

onbeforeunload might get you there, but any site that uses that for any reason other than making sure I don't lose any unsaved changes is the devil.

michaelbuckbee9y ago

If it comes up on exit-intent and doesn't steal focus, they don't seem that bad. An issue is that the triggering is worse on mobile and can be flaky if you're an advanced user (aka like you are on HN and you Ctrl+Click a bunch of links to open in new tabs and then read them in a batch) - those sort of behaviors can trip the exit intent prematurely.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

bradleyankrom9y ago

gjm119y ago

Well, if the user is like me then having just put up a big content-obscuring popup is an excellent sign that the user is about to leave.

bradleyankrom9y ago

Nadya9y ago

Watch for the mouse along the upper 10px of the window [0] or use of the [Ctrl] key (for Ctrl+L or Ctrl+W). Or as other said, for a threshold of upper/upper-left mouse movement.

    1) Change to another tab
    2) Close the tab
    3) Type a new search/website in the Omnibar

[0] http://i.imgur.com/ihiAcHe.png

JimDabell9y ago

That's really irritating because you get false positives (not "false flag", that's something else entirely) whenever you go to change tabs with the mouse.

If somebody is interested in subscribing, then a subscribe box at the bottom or side of the content is fine.

1 more reply

digitalengineerOP9y ago

Most people move to the left and up ;-) (Basically to the back button). See: http://optinmonster.com/how-it-works/ (WARNING: POP-UP! Ha ha

Lxr9y ago

Scrolling up seems pretty popular. Why wouldn't you want a half-page menu telling you what to read next when you scroll up to check something?

GrinningFool9y ago

Why would you? You're not scrolling up to get recommendations, you're scrolling up to re-read content.

Or at least, that's me. If I want to go back to navigation, I hit the Home key (the vast majority of systems do have one or two of them...). If I'm scrolling up, it's to read.

csallen9y ago

It's typically done when the user's mouse leaves the page.

eric_h9y ago

onbeforeunload might get you there, but any site that uses that for any reason other than making sure I don't lose any unsaved changes is the devil.

michaelbuckbee9y ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse