Linus was not talking about the object headers, but about the object contents. It's harder to make the colliding objects look like sane C code, without some strange noise in the middle (which wouldn't be accepted by the project maintainers).

Yes, it's a "C project"-centric view, but consider the date: it was the early days of git. The main way of receiving changes was emailed patches, not pull requests. Binary junk would have a hard time getting in. And even if it did get in, the earliest copy of the object wins, as long as the maintainers added "--ignore-existing" to the rsync command in their pull scripts (yeah, this thread seems to be from before the git fetch protocol), as mentioned earlier in the thread.