undefined | Better HN

0 pointszaroth9y ago0 comments

ACA has got to be the largest tax increase ever foisted on the middle class.

We already have a progressive tax, but let's add an individual mandate, tax credits that phase out at 400% FPL, and cost sharing subsidies which phase out after 250% of FPL.

The maximum value of the tax credits for your family would be nearly the full cost of the premiums at 133% FPL, let's say $12,000. Then on top of that the cost sharing reductions would reduce your out-of-pocket maximum -- which if you're truly unlucky could run your family another $14,300 -- to a maximum of $4,500, so that's worth potentially another $10k.

What this means is ACA is a $12,000 - $22,000 tax on your family depending on your health care utilization, as income rises from 133% - 400% FPL.

For a family of 4 the 133% FPL = $32,250 and 400% = $97,000. So as you make that extra $64,750, in addition to all the other taxes you are paying, you are also phasing in $12,000 - $22,000 of increased payments for the same exact health care. Now that is one hell of a tax.

So while you and your spouse are working your asses off to earn $150k, you can look back and appreciate how $10k went to the town, $10k to the state, $30k to the Fed and ~$15k to the SSA. So it's really just the cherry you're being charged an extra $15k for insurance, come on, you can afford it!

I won't mention all the other subsidies you lose out on for being a productive member of society. Because when you realize the real tax rate approaches 100% on the first $97,000 it's a bit of a buzz kill.

0 comments

2 comments · 2 top-level

grandalf9y ago

Very true. And all that extra money is helping to fund companies like Mylan when they overprice the epi pen for several years.

Why wouldn't they, customers are insulated from the sticker price but can't really complain because high priced health "insurance" is required.

It's just a coincidence that Mylan took any flak for its abuse of the system. Many other pharmaceuticals are increasing in price way out of proportion to inflation, and way out of step with reality since the R&D costs are all borne before product launch.

timr9y ago

"ACA has got to be the largest tax increase ever foisted on the middle class."

That's just Not Even Wrong.

Your health insurance premium is not a "tax". You're getting health insurance. Moreover, not getting a subsidy for your health insurance is also not a tax. You can only use that logic when the tax credit is offsetting another tax. Which it isn't. It's offsetting your health insurance bill.

If, instead, you're trying to claim that every bit of increase in health insurance costs since the ACA is a "tax", that's maybe a bit more defensible, but still Wrong. Health insurance costs have been skyrocketing for decades. The ACA has probably slowed down that trend.

Finally, if you're just complaining that you're healthy but you have to pay for health insurance now...take a walk, please. Eventually, we all get sick. Health insurance only works if healthy people foot the bill of the sick people. That's how insurance works.

2 more replies

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse