undefined | Better HN

0 pointsdragandj9y ago0 comments

You are writing this comment in the lisp-based software. Yeah, I know, Hacker news is a simple software and could have been written in anything else, but, somehow, the author, who I've heard is very smart, thought that Lisp is the best pick.

0 comments

2 comments · 1 top-level

jodrellblank9y ago· 1 in thread

And his secret to winning big was "write lisp software, have it bought out by another company who will rewrite it in a different language to make it popular and useful".

Really, if PG's "LISP, how to win big" was as compelling and important as he tried to state in that essay, every ycombinator company would be using LISP for their secret advantage over other companies.

Applicants would choose LISP because it's "better", LISP-based applications would be preferred because the applicants have an advantage, existing companies would be encouraged to LISP because it would help them do more for less employee numbers and YC would become a LISPy community of alumni.

I have no proof that this is not happening right now, but would you bet on it happening right now in secret?

dragandjOP9y ago

Your logic assumes that young founders/developers are very proficient in many languages (including lisp) and they have perfect information for choosing. In reality, they use whatever crap they picked up hacking in high school. On top of that, the tools are only a part of the ingredients. However bad your platform is, at least it works, while most of the screw-up is hidden in business decisions - that's why every startup incubator's job is to help the youngsters not screw up business-wise. Tech is normally something up to the founders, most of whom have never heard of lisp.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse