> Does that mean I believe the "#3 killer" claim? Not necessarily. But I'd bet that the problem is worse than most medical professionals would expect, and that there remains considerable room for improvement.
Yes exactly, that's my position.
I feel that doctors are overworked generally, don't sleep very much so it's not surprising they don't have the time for introspection on this subject. The error rate is probably largely caused by economic factors like the perpetual labour shortage (in Ireland/UK at least).
On a personal level my grandmother had her pelvis snapped by doctors.
http://www.irishcentral.com/news/irish-woman-awarded-600000-...
In my own experience with a (not life threatening) medical procedure I went to three different doctors asking for help. None was given. They ignored my requests for analysis and a solution. I didn't even know what was wrong.
Finally I went online, found out what the problem was about, found out what the solution could be for it, and then I literally took a flight to England to get an experienced medical practitioner to sort it out which he did very professionally for a reasonable fee.
After this I complained to the medical ombudsman. Only then did they get into a flutter after literally years of waiting for them to solve the problem. A solution was provided that I no longer needed and I told them so. In fact I had already told them so but they weren't paying much attention. Pretty sure I could have sued them into the ground for malpractice.
I work with a coworker who broke his ankle falling down from a ladder. A horrible injury that shattered. That didn't even turn out to be the real problem though because after going into the hospital a doctor didn't wash his hands, and put them into the wound, infecting it with MRSA. My coworker who was awake, literally asked him to wash his hands right there and the doctor said "No, it's Ok".
I'm just one guy in his twenties and I can think of 3 cases like this. That is not good!
Lastly on an optimistic note my uncle fell off a roof he was working on with roof tiling. He fell two stories and behind him a trolley containing roof tiles slipped down and onto his back, almost snapping his spine in two.
The doctors fixed him up with steel plates, taking them out years later. Now he walks around like nothing happened (still on roofs!) but it's an amazing feat of medical attention to detail that this is true given his spinal column was almost severed.