I'm in favour of bringing back the Education Maintenance Allowance, and making it very slightly performance-related.
However, I am not in favour of Government handouts. How much money did it cost to give me £80 back? £100? £150?
Would it not be better to reduce my tax so I pay £80 less each month?
Straight handouts appear to be by far the most effective way of reducing poverty and its negative effects. It's rather like the War On Drugs; you can choose a system that moralises at people or one that improves their outcomes, but if you want to improve outcomes you have to give up moralising control.