undefined | Better HN

0 pointsgrahamburger9y ago0 comments

Honest question, I must be missing something here - Why does your bank need to participate? I just add the card number from any credit or debit card and tap to pay just works. I don't use any of the banks on the supported list.

EDIT: Taking a stab at answering my own question - it looks like you can only set up ACH drafts from the list of supported banks, but as far as I can tell you can use any major credit card to fund purchases.

EDIT AGAIN: As pointed out below, this only works for me because I added these cards in to the old app and they were grandfathered in.

0 comments

toomuchtodo9y ago

Because Apple/Android Pay are token systems that require integrations with a bank's backend systems.

EDIT: Apple uses a tokenized system, each transaction nets them a fee. Google has a hack for the payment network, it costs them for each transaction.

grahamburgerOP9y ago

Then why does it work for me without said integration?

thought_alarm9y ago

I believe Google Wallet works with any credit card because the payments go through Google, and then Google bills your card.

NFC tokenized payments (e.g., Apple Pay and Android Pay) use an alternative credit card number issued by the bank. Payments do not go through Google or Apple, and only the bank knows that this alternate number is associated with your credit card account.

1 more reply

ianburrell9y ago

Android Pay grandfathered cards that were entered in the old app. Those still use virtual credit card if the bank doesn't support tokenization.

After grace period, Android Pay no longer supports adding cards without support from bank and tokenization. For example, I had deleted my Chase card and get an error about bank not being supported if I try to add it.

grahamburgerOP9y ago

Ah that's interesting - I wondered if that might be the case. Mine have all been in there for a while. Seems like they'd have to as they're probably losing money every time I make a transaction. I guess I better not delete any of mine then :)

jdmichal9y ago

When they say "bank", the term used in payments processing is "issuing bank", or more simply "issuer". The issuer is the entity that processes your application and issues you a card. They are responsible for approving purchases [0] on cards they issue and settling with the merchants.

So that list is basically the set of issuing banks which have done whatever steps are necessary to integrate with Android Pay.

[0] Typical flow looks something like this:

The merchant signs up with a payment processor who issues them a POS; this is the machine you swipe your card through. That swipe goes to the payment processor's network, which looks at the first 6 card digits, otherwise known as the Issuer Identification Number [1], and routes to the appropriate card network. For instance, any card starting with "37xxxx" is going to route to AmEx. The card network then routes to the issuing bank, who actually approves (or not) the transaction.

So POS -> Payment Processor -> Card -> Issuer.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_card_number#Issuer_identi...

grahamburgerOP9y ago

I think the point I'm trying to make is that you don't need to be using one of those banks to be using Android Pay. I use Android Pay for tap-to-pay purchases regularly and do not use one of the supported banks. You can use Android Pay with any major credit or debit card.

jdmichal9y ago

I'll refer you to here: https://www.android.com/pay/#supported-networks

Note the verbiage on the second section of the supported issuers: "Add a card from any of these participating banks and continue to get the same rewards, benefits, and security of your cards."

I have a feeling that unless the issuing bank is supported, that Google is basically routing the payment through themselves. (Your responses on the other thread seems to confirm this.) So basically, Google bills your card directly, and they somehow route the money to the merchant. (Not sure what would the the "normal" way to do that; a bit out of my depth. I could probably ask people if you really want to know.) This means that, for instance, if your card gives a bonus for restaurants, and you use Android Pay and the issuer is not supported, that you likely will not get that bonus. Because according to your card the merchant is actually Google and not the restaurant.

So basically, Google is acting as a middle man in the transaction. They (somehow) pay the merchant in lieu of your card, then bill your card directly. This would not happen with a supported issuer; the payment would proceed as it normally would without Google and you get all your sweet, sweet reward points.

1 more reply

mplewis9y ago

Are you talking about Android Pay, or Samsung Pay?

grahamburgerOP9y ago

Android Pay

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

toomuchtodo9y ago

Because Apple/Android Pay are token systems that require integrations with a bank's backend systems.

EDIT: Apple uses a tokenized system, each transaction nets them a fee. Google has a hack for the payment network, it costs them for each transaction.

grahamburgerOP9y ago

Then why does it work for me without said integration?

thought_alarm9y ago

I believe Google Wallet works with any credit card because the payments go through Google, and then Google bills your card.

1 more reply

ianburrell9y ago

Android Pay grandfathered cards that were entered in the old app. Those still use virtual credit card if the bank doesn't support tokenization.

grahamburgerOP9y ago

jdmichal9y ago

So that list is basically the set of issuing banks which have done whatever steps are necessary to integrate with Android Pay.

[0] Typical flow looks something like this:

So POS -> Payment Processor -> Card -> Issuer.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_card_number#Issuer_identi...

grahamburgerOP9y ago

jdmichal9y ago

I'll refer you to here: https://www.android.com/pay/#supported-networks

Note the verbiage on the second section of the supported issuers: "Add a card from any of these participating banks and continue to get the same rewards, benefits, and security of your cards."

1 more reply

mplewis9y ago

Are you talking about Android Pay, or Samsung Pay?

grahamburgerOP9y ago

Android Pay

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse