undefined | Better HN

0 pointsscrollaway10y ago0 comments

It's quite ironic how you're lecturing people about dependencies and bandwidth when you yourself don't seem to have a good grasp in your mind of how immense even 5 kilobytes is (you talk about 5kb functions). 5 kilobytes (well, KiB) is 5120 bytes. That's about 200-300 lines of code. If you're talking about minimized code, maybe up to 500 lines.

0 comments

eterm10y ago

While a 5kb function is immense, I work on a legacy code base and I have seen functions up to 2000 lines long. You possibly overestimate the quality of code that people in business actually write. I've worked in a few places and all have parts of the code which I would thought were made up if submitted to the dailywtf.

Also, have you ever seen a commercial library require >2MB of minified JS? Here's an example:

http://cdn.wijmo.com/jquery.wijmo-pro.all.3.20153.84.min.js

That file is almost 2MB minified (5.6MB unminified).

And that is is only 1 of the few different files required for our dependency on it, there is a bunch more javascript/css also required. Would I use that library on a new product? I'd probably advise against it due to the size, but a legacy product has dependencies and you don't have the freedom to rewrite everything all the time.

scrollawayOP10y ago

I've dealt with such functions, but they're seldom the type of functions that other GGP is talking about (small, simple, exportable functions).

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse