undefined | Better HN

0 pointstzier10y ago0 comments

Portion of payroll taxes is ~7.5%, plus an extra 2.5-10% for workers comp/etc depending on your rates.

If they had to reclass as employees, they would just raise prices to end consumer 10-20% to compensate (or fund it via other's money like they're doing now to price out rest of market).

They'd also put a cap on hours per week so drivers couldn't drive more than 30 hours per week. Companies aren't legally required to give benefits to part-time workers (up to 30 hours).

The big draw of independent contractors is that you've just converted labor from a fixed cost to a variable cost. There are tons of Uber/Lyft drivers (namely, anyone not doing it full-time, which is the majority of drivers) who prefer this since they can drive as much or as little as they want.

0 pointstzier10y ago0 comments

Portion of payroll taxes is ~7.5%, plus an extra 2.5-10% for workers comp/etc depending on your rates.

If they had to reclass as employees, they would just raise prices to end consumer 10-20% to compensate (or fund it via other's money like they're doing now to price out rest of market).

They'd also put a cap on hours per week so drivers couldn't drive more than 30 hours per week. Companies aren't legally required to give benefits to part-time workers (up to 30 hours).

0 comments

5 comments · 2 top-level

azylman10y ago· 3 in thread

> If they had to reclass as employees, they would just raise prices to end consumer 10-20% to compensate (or fund it via other's money like they're doing now to price out rest of market).

I think saying that they would "just" raise prices 10-20% is trivializing the problem. One of the reasons that Uber took off was because it was so much cheaper than regular taxis. Would Uber look the same now if it had had 20% higher prices from the beginning? Almost surely not.

tzierOP10y ago

If their costs had been 20% higher, they still would have priced others out of the market by using VC money to subsidize (as they still do now). Technically their prices were higher than cabs, since they were only black cars for the first two years.

I personally never take cabs anymore even if they're cheaper, the Uber experience is 10x better IMO. The only time I'll consider it is when I use Flywheel on NYE to avoid surge pricing.

rayiner10y ago

I take Uber almost daily from the train to my office because it's about 30% cheaper than a cab. If it wasn't I'd just grab a cab at the cab line. It's so much easier.

harryh10y ago

Of course if uber has to raise rates because their employee costs go up, you'd have to expect cab companies to do the same because all their employees aren't getting benefits either.

1 more reply

wikyd10y ago

For payroll taxes they could also just pay 7.5% less and net take-home pay would be similar for drivers.

The real draw of independent contractors is the reduction in capital expenditures. They don't need to buy and service cars or pay for mileage. Paying for standby time is also probably prohibitively expensive.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse