undefined | Better HN

0 pointsvaishaksuresh10y ago0 comments

>Heck, I might not even mind some gated internet in the US if I was free to opt-in/out of it and it reduced my internet costs.

The key difference is you would still have choice in the US and people in India would not.

0 comments

asift10y ago

I want people in India to have a choice. They can choose to accept Zuckerburg's free internet or they can wait for something else to come along.

It's Zuckerburg's critics that want to deny Indians their right to choose by taking away their free service and leaving them without internet in the present. As was noted earlier, the most vocal critics in this situation are not the poor people in India that are most directly impacted by this situation.

vaishaksureshOP10y ago

This issue is not about having a particular choice or not having anything. Accepting this paves the way for facebook to control the internet that a majority of people are seeing for the first time. Also, it is not really a land-grab as the title says, it is grabbing an untapped market with millions of new users. Facebook most likely wants to mine data from a new potential market.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

asift10y ago

I want people in India to have a choice. They can choose to accept Zuckerburg's free internet or they can wait for something else to come along.

vaishaksureshOP10y ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse