undefined | Better HN

0 pointsAce1710y ago0 comments

There are simpler and less intrusive ways to solve outside-AST issues (like an automatic reformatting pass before each build or each diff)

What you're suggesting raises a bunch of new (non-trivial) issues:

- What would you do with code comments? Things like "f(/+old_value+/new_value)".

- How to store code before preprocessing (C and C++) ?

- How to store files mixing several languages (PHP, HTML, Javascript) ?

- How do you store code for a DSL?

0 comments

> - What would you do with code comments? Things like "f(/+old_value+/new_value)".

Comments are included in the AST, the AST should be reprojectable into canonical plaint text.

> - How to store code before preprocessing (C and C++) ?

This could get tricky, punt. cdata

> - How to store files mixing several languages (PHP, HTML, Javascript) ?

Same file format, different semantics. PHP is a DSL.

My new language manifesto includes having a mandatory publicly defined AST.

If it is reprojectable into canonical plain text, it's not really an AST - just an ST.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse