undefined | Better HN

0 pointsdeathanatos10y ago0 comments

It's not just that Lua makes a good config file format, it's that serving HTTP requests is a complicated enough business with enough edge cases and corner cases that it merits a turning complete language.

I actually have some special corner case API endpoints that nginx just simply can not handle in the manner I would prefer. Further, the regex based location syntax, and even the prefix based ones, are not really what you want; you want a "Path" object that's aware of what / in a URL means, and does the right thing if you do/don't add it to the URL. (And it's not as easy as "/foo/bar/baz/?")

0 comments

2 comments · 1 top-level

SomeCallMeTim10y ago· 1 in thread

In Nginx, you can use Lua for complex routing and responses, with the right extensions. [1]

[1] http://openresty.org/

deathanatosOP10y ago

And we do. We don't use openresty (at least at the moment), we use a custom-built nginx that includes — among other things — the lua module. It's a great boon, but something things are still hard or impossible[1], and we don't use it for every request, opting for the location syntax, and all its flaws, for most.

[1]. Conditionally streaming an upload to a backend (i.e., if auth fails, don't stream) is impossible; nginx will buffer the entire request body, either in memory or on disk, and there is no way to change this behavior.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse